
hello everyone! today i am going to be talking about city of villains by Estelle Laure. i gave this book 1/5 stars. but, thank you so much Disney books and Netgalley for an arc of this book! and all of the thoughts on this book are my own, and didn’t get changed because i got an arc. and also happy pub day for this book!
i feel like in any fantasy book, or book that takes place in the real world, but turned fictional. the author really needs to explain everything how this world works. where in this case Laure did not do this. she pretty much was like yeah this takes place in this fake New York and then would talk about the schools and the different takes on the different disney worlds (ex. Wonderland was a big one) but they never explained it. like it was so confusing and it just didn’t make sense at all. and this was for the world, the schools, and all of the bars/clubs if you could even call it that. and like it was so confusing because it was talking about Michigan and the Bachelor, so i don’t even know what was happening in here.
but, i do think it was kind of cool that we got to see a lot of these disney villains. like it was cool, but half of them didn’t make any damn sense. like the mad hatter made sense, and like the fairies in sleeping beauty made sense, but that was literally it. which, was so confusing, especially when they had three different girls that changed to villains, and the only one made sense and the other two i had like question marks around my head cause i was so confused.
then the writing. this writing was honestly such a god damn mess. everything was like i read this, i did this, i said this, i examined this. so, you get the point. which, this got to be a pain in the ass because it just was so boring. and like it was just not it. but, i mean this was honestly kind of a shit show.
and i’m not sure if this was just me, but i found like writing to be a little childish. like not one of these typical middle grade writing style, this was just plain childish when this was supposed to be this upper YA book. but, now this was just so not good in my mind. and like with what is talked about it feels like older YA, with all the swearing too and all the marriage plot, but then the writing told me something else.
if you follow me, you know that i a lot of my reviews are way more negative then not. but, in here there is literally nothing positive about it. like i read the first maybe 75% word for word then i just skimmed it cause i literally could not care about this world. but, in here i literally cannot think of one positive thing sometimes though i like to put a little positive thing. but, there is not one positive thing in here, not on single thing.
personally, i really like crime books, i really like the stories about people going missing and getting killed. and this seems to be like such a good story combining two things i love, disney and crime stories. but this is not it. and like it was all about how these girls where going missing but it was just not it. like this was just so crappy and did not do anything remotely good.
this is kind of jumping back to the whole world building, but they would have all of these characters that i can pin point being like ‘oh that is supposed to be Maleficent’ or ‘that boy is kind of like Jafar.’ but, then there would be these characters named Kyle and Lucas, and i was like huh??? how does that even make sense.
honestly, this whole book felt like a CW tv show. it is all over the place and does not make any bit of sense at all.
and i’m such a big disney fan. like right as i’m writing this i have a disney jacket on and a walt disney t shirt on. hell i have one whole wall that is filled up with disney world maps and the other one i have a ton of pictures on, and one of my all time favorite books is the kingdom keepers. so, you get how i really love disney, but this was just so bad and did not do it justice. the villains did not make sense at all and this whole world was not it, and it was so weird.
i completely know that this review makes zero sense and is literally all over the place, but there is no way to talk about this book in a cohesive way. so, honestly i’m sorry if you got this far and this does not make sense at all. needless to say i’m not going to read this series.
anyway, that is all for today! i hope you understood this review even a little bit. but, thanks so much for an arc of this book to Netgalley and and Disney books. but, yeah i won’t be reading this series or anything else by the author in the future.

